Transformers in Tunnels and Underground Stations: Fire Safety Considerations
Traction substations, station supplies, ventilation and tunnel boring machines all need transformers. Underground, heat, smoke and access problems are amplified – and this shapes the choice of transformer type and insulating liquid.
Updated 12 November 2026 · Published by IsoTec
Why underground is different
- Heat and smoke stay in the structure. Smoke can reach escape routes and platforms quickly.
- Evacuation and firefighting take longer. Access routes are long; firefighters work in smoke and heat.
- Space is limited. Clearances that are easy above ground are often impossible in a cross-passage or a station plant room.
- Water and dirt. Humidity, condensation, dust and brake debris affect insulation.
- Vibration from trains loosens connections and can create hot spots.
- Drainage paths. Spilled liquid and firewater can enter tunnel drainage.
- High consequence of outage. A failure can stop a line for days.
Where transformers are found
- Traction power substations, including rectifier transformers for DC systems
- Auxiliary and station supplies: lighting, escalators, signalling, pumps
- Tunnel ventilation and smoke extraction plants
- Technical rooms in cross-passages and service tunnels
- Road tunnel lighting, ventilation and safety systems
- Construction power, including transformers on tunnel boring machines
Transformer options compared
| Dry-type (cast resin, F1) | Ester-filled (K-class) | Mineral oil (O-class) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liquid fire (pool or spray) | None | Unlikely pool fire; spray possible during an arc | Pool and spray fires possible |
| Combustible material | Resin and insulation | Ester, cellulose | Mineral oil, cellulose |
| Humidity, dust, condensation | Sensitive – environmental class (E) matters | Sealed tank, insensitive | Sealed tank, insensitive |
| Overload capability | Limited | Good | Good |
| Size and weight per MVA | Larger | Compact | Compact |
| Containment needed | No | Yes | Yes |
| Typical underground use | Lower and medium ratings, stations | Where ratings, space or environment favour liquid-filled units | Usually avoided |
Manufacturers report service experience with ester-filled power transformers up to 420 kV and offer them with rupture-resistant tanks for underground substations. A detailed comparison: ester vs mineral oil vs dry-type.
Standards context
Tunnel fire safety standards look at the system as a whole – fire load, compartmentation, ventilation, evacuation and firefighting. Examples are NFPA 130 for fixed guideway transit and passenger rail, NFPA 502 for road tunnels, and in the EU the technical specification for interoperability on safety in railway tunnels (TSI SRT, Regulation (EU) No 1303/2014). The transformer enters the fire strategy as a fire load and an ignition source; the installation itself follows IEC 61936-1 and national rules. More: IEC 61936-1, FM Global and NEC.
Design measures
- Fire-rated plant rooms (EI/REI) with self-closing fire doors; no escape routes through the room
- K-class insulating liquid – also in tap changers – or a dry-type transformer of fire class F1
- Dry bushings and plug-in or air-insulated cable connections
- Fast electrical protection, pressure relief device and sudden pressure relay; rupture-resistant tank
- Automatic detection; suppression by water mist or sprinklers where required
- Smoke separation from evacuation routes; ventilation that does not draw smoke towards platforms
- Containment that keeps liquid and firewater out of tunnel drainage
- Remote condition monitoring: temperature, pressure, dissolved gas analysis
- Vibration-proof connections and access for inspection
Residual risks specific to tunnels
- Smoke from any fire in the plant room reaching evacuation routes
- Cable fires spreading into or out of the transformer room
- Spills reaching the tunnel drainage system
- Late detection of developing faults because inspection access is restricted
- External fire exposure from a burning train or vehicle near the substation
The full register: residual fire risks of ester-filled transformers.
Checklist for the fire strategy
- List all transformers, their location, rating, liquid volume and liquid class.
- Check every separate liquid volume: bushings, tap changer, cable boxes.
- Define credible fire scenarios and their ignition sources.
- Confirm protection clearing times and pressure relief arrangements.
- Define fire separation, detection and suppression.
- Model smoke movement for the relevant scenarios.
- Plan containment and drainage.
- Agree the residual risk with the client, the authority and the insurer.
Support from IsoTec
We provide fire-relevant data for our K-class ester fluids, support retrofilling of existing transformers and test fluid samples. See the transformer fire safety guide.
Frequently asked questions
Which transformer is best for a tunnel?
There is no single answer. Dry-type units avoid liquid fires but are sensitive to humidity and dirt and have limited overload capacity. Ester-filled units suit higher ratings and harsh environments but need containment and protection against arc faults.
Is mineral oil allowed in tunnels?
It depends on national rules and the project’s fire strategy. Because of its low fire point, mineral oil is usually avoided in underground locations.
Which standards apply to transformers in rail tunnels?
The installation follows IEC 61936-1 and national rules. The tunnel fire strategy is shaped by standards such as NFPA 130 and, in the EU, the TSI on safety in railway tunnels.
Related articles
- Fire Safety of Ester-Filled Transformers
- Residual Fire Risks of Ester-Filled Transformers
- Ester vs Mineral Oil vs Dry-Type Transformers: Fire Risk Compared
- Indoor Transformer Fire Protection: IEC 61936-1, FM Global and NEC
Sources and further reading
- Commission Regulation (EU) No 1303/2014 – TSI Safety in Railway Tunnels (EUR-Lex)
- Transformer Magazine: Modern power transformers for underground substations (2020)
- Petersen, A.: Risk Equals Probability Times Consequences – T&D World (2014)
- Reid, J.: The Use of Ester based Transformer Liquids for Reduced Fire Risk and Lower Costs – IChemE Hazards 31 (2021)
- IEEE C57.156-2016: Guide for Tank Rupture Mitigation of Liquid-Immersed Power Transformers and Reactors
Planning transformers underground?
We help you specify K-class ester fluids and provide the fire data your strategy needs. IsoTec products are supplied to customers outside Germany.

